Our Menu – Pudgies of Williamsport (2024)

Half-N-Half - Sheet

27.99

Our most popular pizza. Take all the pepperoni from the whole pizza....and put them on 1 side!!! Perfect for the house divided. Cheese lovers?.....HAPPY!! Pepperoni lovers?.......DOUBLY HAPPY!!

Medium Pizza, 8 slices

10.49

Additional full topping $2.29

Large Pizza - 16" round 12 slice

12.99

Additional full topping $3.29

Deep Dish - 14" square 16 slice

13.49

Additional full topping $3.29

Sheet Pizza, 32 slice

22.99

Additional full topping $4.49

Toppings

Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Sausage, Ham, Bacon, Meat Sauce, Ground Beef, Chicken (extra charge), Onions, Pineapple, Sweet Peppers, Black Olives, Banana Peppers, Extra Cheese.

Meat Lovers - Medium

16.49

A delicious combination of Pepperoni, Ham, Bacon, Sausage and Meat Sauce with just the right amount of cheese.

--Large or Deep Dish

21.49

--Sheet

36.99

Buffalo Chicken - Medium

16.49

A gooey concoction of cream cheese, buffalo sauce, chunk chicken on our delicious crust topped with Mozzarella.

--Large or Deep Dish

21.49

Cheesesteak Pizza - Medium

16.99

Perhaps our finest creation! Try it once and you'll be hooked forever.

-- Cheese Steak Pizza Large or Deep Dish

22.49

Plain Slice

2.49

A huge slice of our thick and cheesy pizza!

Pepperoni Slice

2.84

A huge slice of our famous pizza topped with Pepperoni

Jumbo Wings 5 Coint

6.99

Jumbo Wings 10 Count

13.99

Jumbo only sold in 10 count, but can be mixed any way you want. Buffalo style -- Mild, Medium, or HotBBQ SaucePlain

Original Boneless Wings - 1 Lb

12.99

Boneless wings are sold by the dozen, but can be mixed any way you want.Buffalo style -- Mild, Medium, or HotBBQ Sauce, Honey BBQ, Carolina Gold, Garlic ParmPlain

Breaded Boneless Strips 1 Lb

12.49

Boneless wings are sold by the dozen, but can be mixed any way you want.Buffalo style -- Mild, Medium, or HotBBQ SaucePlain

Family Wing Pack

28.99

Combines a Large or Deep Dish Cheese Pizza, 10 Jumbo Wings (or Full Size Entree substitute which can increase or decrease the price of the pack) and a 2 Liter of Soda. Additional toppings are $2.99 each. . Perfect for 3-4 people to share.

Pudgie Wing Pack

51.49

Combines a 32 slice Sheet Pizza, 20 Jumbo Wings (or Full Size Entree substitutes which can increase or decrease the price of the pack) and a 2 Liter of Soda. Additional toppings are $3.99 each. Perfect for 8-10 people to share. Mix and match pasta and wings to bring home something for everyone!

Max Wing Pack

79.99

Combines a 32 slice Sheet Pizza, 40 Jumbo Wings (or Full Size Entree substitutes which can increase or decrease the price of the pack) and two 2-liters of Soda. Additional toppings are $3.99 each. Perfect for 10-12 people to share. Mix and match pasta and wings to bring home something for everyone!

Pasta With Red Sauce (single serving)

3.99

Our delicious homemade red sauce served on your choice of penne or spaghetti, topped with a delicious blend of Pico Romano cheese for that classic Italian taste.Served with 2 homemade breadsticks.

Pasta With Red Sauce (Full Entree)

6.99

served with 4 homemade breadsticks

Pasta with Meatsauce (single serving)

8.49

Our homemade red sauce with a generous helping of ground beef.Served with 2 homemade breadsticks

Pasta with Meatsauce (Full Size Entree)

11.99

Served with 4 homemade breadsticks

Baked Ziti (single serving)

9.49

Our delicious red sauce and ground beef, mixed together with penne pasta and smothered in mozzarella cheese, then we oven bake it to lock in all that delicious flavor!Served with 2 homemade breadsticks.

Baked Ziti (Full Size Entree)

12.99

Served with 4 homemade breadsticks

Add 2 Meatballs

1.50

Our amazing meatballs are the perfect addition to any pasta dish!

Creamy Alfredo (single serving)

7.99

Creamy Alfredo sauce smothering your choice of pasta.Add grilled chicken for $3.00Add broccoli for $1.00Served with 2 homemade breadsticks

Creamy Alfredo (Full Size Entree)

11.99

Add grilled chicken $3.00Add broccoli $1.00Served with 4 homemade breadsticks

Creamy Pesto Alfredo (single serving)

8.99

Our creamy Alfredo sauce infused with a delicious Pesto sauce. Simply Amazing!Add grilled chicken for $3.00served with 2 homemade breadsticks

Creamy Pesto Alfredo (Full Size entree)

12.99

Add grilled chicken $3.00Served with 4 homemade breadsticks

Tortellini

3 / 4

Choose our delicious cheese stuffed tortellinis instead of penne or spaghetti for any pasta dish!Single serving, adds $3.00Full Size entree adds $4.00

Meat Ball Platter

11.99

A delicious oven baked concoction of our delicious meatballs, red sauce and Mozzarella cheese! You can also try it with any of our wing sauces in place of the red sauce.

Stromboli - Small

14.99

Our version of a classic. Comes with Mozzarella and American Cheese, Pepperoni, Sausage, Sweet Peppers and Just the right amount of Pizza Sauce.

Stromboli - Large

19.49

Meat Lovers Stromboli - Small

15.99

Pepperoni, Ham, Bacon, Sausage & Meat Sauce. Perfect for the meat lover in your family or office. (No Substitutions)

Meat Lovers Stromboli - Large

21.49

2 Plain Slices and a Small Fountain Soda

5.99

2 Slice Pepperoni and Small Soda

6.69

Cold Deal of a Meal

10.29

Any Cold Sub paired with an order of fries and a small fountain soda.

Hot Deal of a Meal

11.79

Any Hot Sub or Cozmo paired with an order of fries and a small fountain soda.

Chicken Tender Deal of a Meal

10.29

Our delicious tenders paired with an order of fries and a small fountain soda.

Cheesesteak Sub

8.49

Our take on the Philly classic. Considered by many to be the best cheesesteak outside of Philly.

Pudgie Burger

8.49

It's a burger, but in hogie form. Classic Americana in a Williamsport's classic place for Pizza, Wings, and Subs.

Chicken Cheesesteak Sub

7.99

Our take on the chicken version of the famous Philly hogie.

Grilled Ham & Cheese

7.99

Meatball Sub

7.99

Chicken Tender Sub

7.99

Garden Salad

5.49

Lettuce, Tomato, Onions, Black Olives & Mozzarella Cheese with your choice of Ranch, Italian or Bleu Cheese dressing.

Cheesesteak Salad

6.49

Our garden salad topped with a full portion of our delicious cheesesteak, cooked fresh on the grill!

Side Salad

3.49

Cheese Sub

5.49

American Swiss, and Provolone Cheese

Turkey Sub

6.99

Super Sub

6.99

Ham, Salami, American or Provolone Cheese. Topped however you like.

Italian Sub

5.99

Hot ham, Salami, American or Provolone Cheese and Oregano. Topped however you like.

Ham Sub

6.99

Ham & Turkey Sub

6.99

Make it a Cozmo!

$.50

Turn any cold sub into a delicious, toasted hot sandwich!

Make it a Meal

$3.30

Turn any sub into a Meal Deal (fries & a small fountain drink)

Chef Salad

6.99

Ham, Turkey, Lettuce, Tomato, Onions, Black Olives & Mozzarella Cheese with your choice of Ranch, Italian or Bleu Cheese dressing.

Chicken Cheesesteak Salad

7.99

Our garden salad topped with a full portion of our delicious chicken cheesesteak, cooked fresh on the grill!

French Fries

$2.49

Our most popular side, because, well....they're FRENCH FRIES and they are perfect with ANYTHING. Don't forget you can substitute most of our sides for the fries by paying the price difference, so be adventurous and mix it up once in awhile!

Cheese Curds

5.29

Waffle Fries

3.49

Add Cheese 1.00Loaded- 3.00

Onion Rings

$4.99

Mozzarella Sticks

$5.99

Chicken Tenders

$7.49

Bread Sticks

$3.99

Battered Mushrooms

5.29

Battered Cauliflower

$5.29